CFA Institute's Board Chair calls for effective Canadian securities
enforcement to restore the public's trust in capital markets and the
TORONTO, Jan. 13 /CNW/ - Margaret Franklin, CFA, chair of the Board of Governors of CFA Institute
today called for fundamental changes to securities enforcement
practices in Canada, including an overhaul of the RCMP's Integrated
Enforcement Market Teams (IMET).
In a speech to The Canadian Club of Toronto, Franklin cited failures in
Canada's enforcement practices while making the case - supported by a
series of recommendations - that strong and efficient enforcement of
the securities industry should be a priority for government, regulators
and investment professionals. Further, Franklin made the case that
effective enforcement is essential to restoring the public's trust in
our capital markets and the investment profession.
"While investing is often seen as elitist and white collar crime is
viewed dramatically differently from gun and gang-related crimes, the
integrity of, and confidence in, our financial system is critically
important to the well-being of this country and should be as much of a
priority as dealing with violence in our communities," Franklin said.
Citing examples such as Bre-X, Crocus, Norbourg, Berkshire and Andrew
Rankin and Daniel Duic, Franklin said, "cases such as these cause the
industry as a whole to suffer as a result of a tainting of the pool and
eroded investor confidence.
"I continue to be shocked that industry participants aren't outraged and
demanding stronger enforcement because this is about our business,
which is about trust."
According to Franklin, one of the most significant weak links in the
chain of enforcement, is IMET. Launched in 2003, this agency is
comprised of 10 investigative units in four cities across Canada and
describes itself as a group of highly specialized investigators dedicated to ensuring that
those who commit serious capital markets fraud offences will be
discovered, investigated, prosecuted, and incarcerated in an effective
and timely fashion.
"At a cost of more than $100 million dollars to Canadian taxpayers, IMET
has a grand total of five convictions from 26 arrests. Without
question, IMET needs to be revamped from top to bottom," she said.
In an effort to address the deficiencies in Canadian securities
enforcement practices, Franklin recommended the following:
To avoid the situation where individuals leave the industry to avoid
having to pay enforcement-related penalties, IIROC and the MFDA should
be granted the statutory ability to collect fines.
That obtaining the Canadian Securities Course should be a minimum requirement for employment as an investigator with a Canadian regulator.
Increase the number of securities lawyers with industry experience,
particularly those with compliance backgrounds, working at the senior
most levels of the provincial securities administrators.
Canada needs to adopt a single, national regulator that will help
streamline detection, investigation, and disciplinary proceedings.
"Consistent with our mission of professional excellence through
education and ethics training, I'm pleased to announce that CFA
Institute will now offer Canadian provincial administrators and SRO
employees easier access to Level 1 of the CFA Program," Franklin said.
Finally, Franklin said that CFA Institute will be calling for a
federally commissioned task force to create the awareness and political
will to tackle these issues. As part of its mandate, this task force
will examine the recommendations from previous task forces - notably
the 2006 Task Force to Modernize Securities Legislation in Canada which provided 33 well-received enforcement-specific recommendations -
with a goal of determining why so few have been introduced.
"We will be inviting others in the industry who share our interest in
regaining investor trust and confidence by enhancing enforcement
practices to join us in the push for this task force. The task force
will be made up of associations and advocates who believe that Canada
needs a fair playing field for all investors."
CFA Institute is the global association for investment professionals. It
administers the CFA and CIPM curriculum and exam programs worldwide;
publishes research; conducts professional development programs; and
sets voluntary, ethics-based professional and performance-reporting
standards for the investment industry. CFA Institute has more than
100,000 members, who include the world's 90,000 CFA charterholders, in
135 countries and territories, as well as 135 affiliated professional
societies in 58 countries and territories. More information may be
found at www.cfainstitute.org.
*A copy of Ms. Franklin's speech is available upon request.
SOURCE CFA Institute
For further information: